What’s in a Name

I’ve had several names throughout my life.

As expected, the first was given to me by my parents. My surname represented my father’s family (also assumed by my mother when they married). My middle name was a common one for girls of my generation with a Catholic family background. I was one of a significant number of girls at my high school with Anne or a variation of Mary as a middle name. 

My first name was chosen by my mother at the last minute, when asked by the hospital staff for the name of the baby (or so the story goes). Up to that point she had planned to name me Bernadette, but instead in the moment of truth another name was given. I’m kind of glad for that – that my name wasn’t one she claimed and cherished as she approached the birth of her first child. Given everything that has happened since that moment, I’m glad my name doesn’t feel like something precious that she and I share somehow, but which she retains ownership of. I am me, with a name allocated at random that I’ve made my own. 

The second ‘name’, a minor variation of the original, was gained when I married at the age of 22. I took my now ex-husband’s surname without no thought of considering the options. A church wedding, Christian background, early 90s social expectations. It wasn’t even something I thought about, other than looking forward to having a surname that was easier for people to spell (my maiden name was of Irish origin with a ‘Mc’ invariably spelled as ‘Mac’ and generally requiring repeated spellings to ensure accuracy if I had to give it over the phone). 

I was married for 22 years and that second surname (my ex-husband’s) was a label for ‘adult me’  in the same way the first surname (my father’s) represented ‘childhood me’. 

Then I left my marriage in my early 40s and that second name no longer seemed right – it no longer represented me and it was a reminder of a version of myself that I no longer identified with. I know many women revert to their maiden name in such circumstances, particularly if they are trying to emotionally distance themselves from an abusive relationship (as I was), however my parents made it clear that they remained connected with and supportive of my ex-husband, and my childhood surname no longer felt safe. It was just a further reminder that I was defined by my connection with people who didn’t value me and treated me like an extension of themselves instead of someone with value in my own right. 

I felt like neither name was the right fit for the transition into my new life, but picking a name at random also felt wrong, like assuming someone else’s identity. So, I continued to use my married name, changed ‘Mrs’ to ‘Ms’, and tried to suppress the wave of revulsion whenever I saw it written anywhere (or had to write it myself). 

This revulsion became a particular issue as my third book was published, almost 18 months after I left my marriage. I had one book published pre-separation, and another that was in the final stages of production during those first months after I left the marriage. Both of these books were published under my married name.

[Side note: interestingly, this revulsion was never triggered by my children’s names, perhaps because there is no sense of them being something that belongs to me (like the books I’ve created or my own identity). Instead, their names reflect who *they* are and aren’t connected with the challenges and internal conflicts I face as I redefine myself.]

For the third book, where I had time to consider options, I decided to use a pseudonym, but I once again came up against the challenge of what name to use. I didn’t want my parents’ or ex-husband’s surname on my book (the thought actually made me feel physically ill), but I didn’t have a name that felt like my own to use. In the end, I chose a pen name that was a variation of my own first name and a surname that was a connection with my grandmother. It appears on my third book, and is linked by the publisher with the other two. If I write more books in this genre I will probably use it, but it doesn’t really feel like my name. It’s more like a label. It’s something functional created to solve a problem, not something I feel a connection with. It doesn’t really represent me, any more than my other ‘hats’ of wife, mother, sister, friend, secretary, writer, or any of a dozen others do. It’s a fragment of a whole. 

I’ve married again and now I have another name, once again taking my husband’s surname as my own. This time I thought about it. I considered my options. I’m still working out how this name fits, but it’s a name I selected by conscious choice, shared by someone who made it clear that I was welcome to claim this outward connection to him, but it was certainly not something that was expected or requested. 

And at the other end of the spectrum is this blog, a place where I chose to have no name, because I needed to feel safe and needed a space where I could simply be, without having to conform to or protect a particular identity. There were privacy issues too, of course. I wanted a space where I could write honestly and directly without worrying about extended family, who were actively trying to undermine me, taking things out of context. And I wanted to minimise the possibility of my writing being connected with my children and further complicating things for them as they processed the impact of the separation and divorce, and their father’s past and ongoing abuse. 

But it’s been almost 3 years since the end of my first marriage, and my children have largely worked out what boundaries they need to maintain for their own wellbeing (although this is under regular review). The anonymity of the blog, though necessary, has always felt like a contradiction to its purpose, which was to help me feel less ‘invisible’ after decades of relationships that forced me to suppress who I really am. So, as I head into the New Year, I’m claiming back another piece of myself by establishing some tenuous links between these words and myself. 

Hello world. My name is Susan. 

How Does This Happen?

A few months after I left my abusive marriage, when I was confused about how I’d stayed in a relationship that was so toxic for so long, how I hadn’t even really realised how toxic it was until various social workers and secular counsellors immediately recommended I contact abuse support services when I shared details, a friend said something that has stayed with me: you don’t realise the air you’re breathing is poisonous until you take a breath of fresh air.

It made sense at the time in relation to my marriage. The reaction of others as I shared details from the 22 years I was with my ex-husband gradually helped me realise that what I’d accepted as ‘normal’ was in fact toxic and dysfunctional to an extreme level. I was surprised, but somehow not surprised, as I took a step back and realised that the relationship that had made me feel so sad and hopeless and isolated wasn’t considered normal by others. 

Then I faced the judgement of Christian friends and my church family for stepping away from my marriage and betraying my wedding vows. I had close Christian friends urge me to return to my ex-husband, even though they were aware social workers and domestic violence counsellors were advising me to protect myself and my children from his manipulation and encouraging me to access support services for abuse victims. Church friends ignored my assertions that he was controlling and toxic and urged me to do the ‘right’ thing for myself and my children and restore our family to what God intended. And I took a step back, took a deep breath and realised that the poisonous air hadn’t just been inside my marriage, it was inside my church too. 

Then my mother assured me she was there for me and I told her my ex-husband had been abusive. She was sympathetic and said she wasn’t surprised that I was so unhappy. She encouraged me to talk to her and lean on her, and in the same breath told me that she would be available to him too, because she loved us equally. When I told her he was stalking me, she said that was very troubling and if he shared anything with her that she thought might indicate there was a problem, she’d definitely let me know (then let me pay for the morning tea that she’d taken me out to for my birthday). 

And when, after months of no contact, I called her to confirm what my ex had told my (confused) kids – that he was planning to have dinner with my parents and they’d sent him a birthday card – I was informed very firmly by my mother that she had no intention of allowing me to tell her who she could talk to and she would most certainly be happy to have my ex visit her any time if that’s what he wanted. Followed up by a vicious text from my father accusing me of maniacal ranting, relentless selfishness, and informing me that I was no longer allowed to contact my mother directly. 

And I took another step back, took a deep breath and realised that the poisonous air had been there from birth. That I’d never breathed fresh air. That I’d been conditioned to accept the poisonous air as normal since childhood. Not just normal, but what I deserved; all I deserved. 

How did this happen? How did I live a functional and ‘normal’ life for so long, gasping for breath? 

I feel stupid and naive – how did I not realise this was happening? Why did I allow other people to define my worth? Why did I accept it when they said I was worth nothing (unless I was exactly what they told me I should be)? Then I feel angry. These were people I trusted, people I should have been able to trust above all others. People who should have loved me unconditionally but didn’t really love me at all. 

And then I just feel overwhelmed and broken and lost. How can I retreat to a place where I feel safe so I can rebuild myself when it’s obvious I’ve never been emotionally safe or accepted for who I am? When my entire sense of self has been defined by others whose only concern was how I made them feel? What does it say about me that those that should have loved me valued me so little (but said they loved me, even though I made it so difficult and was so unloveable). 

It isn’t possible to rebuild myself, because who I thought I was is built on lies and manipulation and judgement. I’m starting over and it’s surreal and awful and terrifying to be 47 years old and have no idea of who I am. I can’t discern the real me from the conditioned and controlled version of myself. I don’t know what I like, what I want, who I am. I feel lost. And I feel so supremely inadequate for the task of moving forward into my new life. 

I need to start over. But where do you start, when your life is already underway? When you have responsibilities and commitments? How do I take the mental time out that I need to work out who I am when I have a full time job, three teenagers and two step-children to encourage and support, and a new husband whose love gives me stability, but also leaves me confused and overwhelmed because I simply don’t know how normal relationships work? Where is the space in my life to work out who I am when I have so many reasons to simply be what everyone else needs me to be? Just like I always have. Just like I’ve been conditioned to do. 

My therapist has been talking with me about core values, about the core of who I am. She’s reassured me that person is good and kind and compassionate. But we’ve had to acknowledge that those characteristics are a response to how I’ve been treated and how others have made me feel. My parents, ex-husband, and church family made me feel so invisible and insignificant and inadequate, that I hate the thought of making others feel that way. A longtime friend jokes that getting people to share random details of their lives with me is my superpower, but the reality is that I hate the thought making others feel isolated and inadequate and I do what I can to help them feel connected and let them know that who they are matters, even if it’s only for the length of a casual interaction.

Which works on a casual level, but proper friendships require substance and I feel like an outline of a person, with no detail and no depth and no focus – a vague shadow that finds it so hard to connect with others. Real friendship requires giving of yourself and I simply don’t know who I am and I feel like I have nothing left to give.

And I wonder again, how does this happen? And how do I find the emotional reserves to move forward, when I feel depleted beyond my ability to recover? 

And I take a deep breath, breathe in fresh air, and face another day. Because I deserve the chance to be who I am and I refuse to let go of the hope that it isn’t too late to find myself underneath the debris of the person I let others tell me I was.